The Asian Stereotype in Israel

 

What do you think the Asian stereotype is in Israel? how do Israelis perceive somebody Asian they see or meet in the streets of Jerusalem or Tel-Aviv?

Since I can’t use very good quantitive research methods, I’ll result to using my simple qualitative methods which are based on my acquaintance with my Asian friends and a my perception of the Israeli media.

 

My Chinese teacher Lin, who’s originally from China, likes to include a lot of stories about herself and her life in our classes. Here’s the 6th sentence of our last homework (class 5) -

6. 這個大學的警衛問我們的漢語老師:“你是誰?你需要不需要我幫你在哪家餐館找一份工作?”

My quick translation - 

A guard at the entrance to the university asked my Chinese teacher : "And you are… ?! Do you want me to help you find work at some restaurant?

(a quick background note - this is about Israel which has very tight security just about everywhere, and that includes guards and metal detectors in the university entrance). Discussing this with Lin before, I’m sure this isn’t a joke.

Most Asians in Israel are foreign workers from Thailand, the Philippines and China that do all kinds of jobs that most Israelis don’t want to do - construction, elderly-care, house-cleaning, agriculture, and stirring up fried-vegetables in Asian fastfood places. As a result, there’s a strong stereotype about Asians and so my Asian friends, who have great jobs or are MA students at the university, are being approached by Israelis who offer them to do house-cleaning or stir-frying. It makes me sad to hear those kind of stories, even though my Asian friends find those amusing.

 

Israel has a very popular satire show called "It’s a wonderful country" or "Eretz Nehederet", and a nice thing about this show is that they put some of the popular scenes up on the web for anybody to watch. This show is always among the top 3 on the ratings list, and has turned into somewhat of a cult-show. I did a very quick review of all the seasons posted on the web to see if any of them include references to Asians and found 3 :

  • A flick about a famous ex-model-businesswoman Pnina Rosenblaum and her Philippine house-maid.
  • A flick about an Israeli travel show called Masa Olami (meaning - world travel) joking about the host exploring the sex scene in Thailand.
  • A flick about how much Israeli families suffer when their Asian foreign workers are deported.

 

Israelis/Jews in Taiwan and China have the problem of being referred to by the stereotype of "very good at making money", which might be annoying but could be much worse when considering other countries’ attitude. As for Taiwanese and Chinese in Israel - I’m a bit worried.

6 Responses so far | Have Your Say!

  1. Noju - Gravatar

    Noju UNITED STATES  |  December 4th, 2006 at 10:53 pm #

    They racistly hate Chinese men so much they actually FORBID them from having sex with Israeli women!!!

  2. Klim - Gravatar

    Klim UNITED STATES  |  October 9th, 2007 at 5:02 am #

    they don’t forbid it.
    its just that by religous rules you need to be a jewish to merrie or to have sex with a man or a woman.
    but not all of the Israelies/Jews are religouse . so stop this shitty excusion becouse one lady didnt give you what you want

  3. 天天北极-Carrie - Gravatar

    天天北极-Carrie CHINA  |  October 10th, 2007 at 1:58 pm #

    during this summer vacation, one of my schoolmates travelled to Australia, worked there to support his daily life and even earned his flight ticket back!!!

    well, it’s so attracted and inspiring for me!

    two of my israeli friends suggested that i could go to israel to teach chinese as part-time, now i’m actually taking this idea very seriously.

    people tell me educated chinese teacher is needed much in israel nowaday, but when i searched jobs on internet, i cannot get much information… kind of frustrated, huh~

    today after reading this “stereotype”, wow, now i’m more frustrated… >_

  4. james cohen - Gravatar

    james cohen TAIWAN  |  October 12th, 2007 at 7:57 pm #

    Why is that a problem? Jews are good at making money, and we like to be “greedy pigs”

  5. fiLi - Gravatar

    fiLi TAIWAN  |  October 13th, 2007 at 6:49 am #

    The main problem with “Jews are good at making money” is that people tend to resent (and I’m using a mild verb) those they believe are holding the power in the world, and in times of frustration and shortage they maybe act against them as a group. I would dare say this statement is one of the tragedies of the Jewish people and has been causing antisemitic problems for the Jewish people repeatedly for centuries.

  6. Petar - Gravatar

    Petar  |  August 5th, 2008 at 1:03 am #

    Some Israely Jews are religous and some ae not…just like in any given place on earth…

Leave a Feedback

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>